One Schoolhouse

  • STUDENT COURSES
    • School Information
    • Student Information
    • Parent & Guardian Information
    • Summer Courses
    • Register
  • ACADEMIC LEADERS
    • Association for Academic Leaders
    • Join the Association
    • Open Doors Blog
  • CONSORTIUM
    • Join the Consortium
    • Our Schools
  • COURSE LOGIN
  • STUDENT COURSES
    • School Information
    • Student Information
    • Parent & Guardian Information
    • Summer Courses
    • Register
  • ACADEMIC LEADERS
    • Association for Academic Leaders
    • Join the Association
    • Open Doors Blog
  • CONSORTIUM
    • Join the Consortium
    • Our Schools
  • COURSE LOGIN

AI Can Write Essays: What Does This Mean for Educators?

12/16/2022

4 Comments

 
Picture
Sarah Hanawald
“A new artificial intelligence chatbot has taken the internet by storm” proclaimed the Washington Post on December 6. From the flood of replies to an independent school techie listserv query (51 as of Thursday morning), independent school folks are curious and wary about what ChatGTP’s AI generated text means for teachers and students. (Need a primer on AI?)
The Association for Academic Leaders Advisory Council met last Friday, and AI was on their minds, too. Several of the members had given the site a try, and the results had impressed,  dismayed, or even encouraged them. Several mentioned that the site seemed to have merit as a “jumping off point” for work to be more developed by the author. A former AP teacher proclaimed an essay “worth at least a 4.” An English teacher followed up after the conversation by saying that while we’d discussed how a student could generate an AI essay and then “back into” an outline and a rough draft or two to appear to have gone through the writing process, she believed that most students who commit academic dishonesty are trying to create shortcuts and that didn’t seem to be much of a shortcut to her. The consensus was that teachers and Academic Leaders would need to explore, understand, and address ChatGTP, as was the case with tools already available in areas such as math, world languages, and art (Wolfram Alpha, AI;R Math, DALL-E and more).

During the conversation, I shared that I’d asked the AI, “How can a teacher tell if an essay is written by AI instead of by the student submitting the work?” (Find ChatGTP’s answer at the end of this post). 

The limits of the AI become evident pretty quickly. The results are hardly inclusive. I asked for novel suggestions and the AI generated a list of books by white authors (and only one woman). Evidence abounds that AI algorithms are biased, can be racist, and “deepen racial and economic disparities.” While the question seems to be how to make AI “better,” schools would do well to ensure that students understand these profound inequities are baked into much, if not all, of the AI they’ll encounter. And of course, there’s the fact that the user’s data “may be reviewed by our AI trainers to improve our systems.” Yup, in using these tools, you’re giving up valuable insights to the companies building the algorithms. For these reasons alone, schools need to teach students about AI, how it works, how using it might help learners, and where they should be cautious rather than ignoring it or trying to find ways to keep students from using it with blockers and other tech tools. 

Peter Gow and I did some further poking at the AI’s capabilities. We found that answers were often circular once the questions got philosophical. “How to end inequity in education?” ChatGTP helpfully offered that we just needed to examine the root causes of inequity in society at large and eliminate those. Problem solved. On the other hand, we played around with a book idea and the resulting outline wasn’t bad for organizing ideas into sections and chapters.

AI generated text is certainly going to be a boon to the publishers of “clickbaity” pieces such as “Top 10 Tips for Tying Shoes” that one might find on a specialty laces shop. So there’s a paying gig for a human gone, and I’ll let others decide whether or not that’s a loss. Canva, a widely-used website for infographic/poster generation, has incorporated AI (dubbed Magic Studio) with the caveat that the use of AI must be credited on the final version of work. Media stories range from the Atlantic proclaiming the “end of the college essay” to the Washington Post celebrating that a dyslexic landscaper has developed new confidence in client communications.  

In trying to think about what this addition to the technology landscape means, both right now and going forward, I engaged in writing this blog post, an activity that helped me organize my thoughts around AI generated text. Organizing one’s thinking is part of every course; teachers can and should consider incorporating AI into this work. The art of generating the right question to elicit an answer to an assignment is worth teaching, just as we teach students how to write search queries. The natural next step is to consider whether you got useful answers. How do you know? Asking students to design powerful questions rather than regurgitate memorized answers is nothing new to independent school faculty! Educators can and should explore the impact of using AI to assist students with communication disorders.

But once the questions are asked, there’s then the value of engaging in the longer writing process, and here’s where it gets trickier. Genuine engagement in writing longer text forces the writer to organize their thoughts, interrogate what’s on paper, see where more research or re-thinking is needed and revise accordingly. Paragraphs move, evidence is cited, false trails are followed, then rejected, Teachers will know that students have engaged in that level of work when they know their students well, engage in dialogue with them while they write (or solve complex math problems or compose music, etc). Further, the culture of the school (this one’s on you, Academic Leaders) needs to prioritize the inclusive work of intellectual engagement, and that of making thinking visible, over the grading of the end piece. 

Oh, and that response I said I’d share?

My question: How can a teacher tell if an essay is written by AI instead of by the student submitting the work?

Response: There are a few ways that a teacher can tell if an essay has been written by AI instead of by the student who submitted it. One way is to look for signs of artificial language, such as repetitive sentences or unnatural word combinations. Another way is to evaluate the content of the essay and see if it is relevant to the topic and meets the requirements of the assignment. The teacher can also look for inconsistencies or errors in the essay that may indicate that it was generated by a machine. Finally, the teacher can ask the student to provide additional information or clarification about the essay to verify that they are the author of the work.

For more on this topic, check out this accompanying blog written by Peter Gow: Using AI's Powers for Good
4 Comments

A Strategy to Consider: Scenario Interviews Can Surface Competencies

12/12/2022

0 Comments

 
One tool for creating a more balanced look at a candidate's competencies is to use a tactic that has been well-documented in other professions, the scenario interview, sometimes called a situational interview. These are interview questions that deal with hypothetical situations in the future and ask the candidate "what would you do in this situation?" Alternatively, you could set up a situation specifically for the interview. For example, you could ask a candidate to give a current teacher feedback on a proposed assignment for a course they'll share. When you use situational interview questions, you offer candidates with a competency the opportunity to demonstrate their skills. 
 
If situational interviews are new to you, or if you have skeptical colleagues, here is a research study that found that situational interviews can predict performance. 
 
The scenario interview does NOT ask a candidate to "describe a time in which you..." That type of question has a couple of flaws. It privileges fast processors and those who have the exact experience addressed in the question.

Association for Academic Leaders members, there’s a conversation about hiring taking place in the portal started by member Lauren Putnam, Middle School Dean of Instruction, Charlotte Latin School. Check out what your peers are saying and sharing!

Interested in learning more about hiring practices? Association for Academic Leaders members get access to our entire Winter/Spring 2023 professional learning calendar, out in January.
0 Comments

Prepare for Hiring in 2023

12/8/2022

0 Comments

 
Picture
Brad Rathgeber
The Great Resignation. Quiet Quitting. Employees experiencing Shift Shock. Demand for remote work is higher than ever (with fewer remote jobs available). The COVID pandemic has upended the labor market in all industries tremendously. Employees are continuing to reassess their goals, motivations for work, and life priorities. And, employers needs are changing. To prepare for the upcoming hiring season, Academic Leaders should take the next few weeks to focus their efforts in four areas that will make a difference.
​Focus on Belonging
Academic Leaders need to ask daily: what can I do to make sure that my team feels valued, and has a sense of belonging at my school? A recent​ McKinsey & Company report showed a disconnect between why employers thought their employees were leaving and why they actually are leaving. The report highlighted that employers need to focus much more on employee’s sense of belonging, employees: “didn’t feel valued by their organizations (54 percent) or their managers (52 percent) or because they didn’t feel a sense of belonging at work (51 percent). Notably, employees who classified themselves as non-White or multiracial were more likely than their White counterparts to say they had left because they didn’t feel they belonged at their companies.” 

Re-Recruit Your Team
It is time to re-recruit your current employees. And yet, January and February are notoriously challenging times in independent schools. Consider what you might do as an Academic Leader to connect deeply with everyone on your team, and reserve time in your calendar now to prioritize those connections. A recent Harvard Business Review article suggested three keys to re-recruitment: spend significant time with each of your employees to understand their motivations and ambitions; make sure that they see their positive impact on the organization and the difference they are making; and make sure that your conversations are on-going, not one and done. 

Get Your Job Descriptions Current
Jobs have changed during the COVID pandemic, but most schools have not, in turn, altered their job descriptions. Academic Leaders will want to make sure that their job descriptions reflect the changes that occurred during the pandemic, including possibilities for job flexibility, the technological acumen required to manage new systems, compliance with local or school health and safety policies, and willingness to take on additional duties as assigned. 

Check in With Your Attorney
The pandemic hasn’t only changed job titles and descriptions–it’s also brought about changes in hiring and employment regulations. As you review openings and positions, it’s a good idea to check in with your attorney before the hiring season begins. A short conversation will help you to understand national and state requirements, and to avoid any pitfalls that could arise in the interview and decision process. More than in any other year, a little foresight and preparation can avoid costly mistakes. 
0 Comments

Twelve Maxims For Hiring & Sustaining Teachers: Is Your School Observing These?

12/7/2022

0 Comments

 
Picture
Peter Gow
“Hiring season” in many schools will commence just after the Holiday Season comes to an end. We offer here a dozen maxims on teacher hiring and care, derived from An Admirable Faculty: Recruiting, Hiring, Training, and Retaining Teachers in Independent Schools by Peter Gow (NAIS, 2005)
MAXIM #1—Every opening is an opportunity
  • No matter how beloved the departee, the new person can be as effective or possibly even more so
  • Look at every opening from an institutional point of view—strategic and practical needs
  • Even Mr. Chips retired at last; but you’re not replacing someone, you are filling a position
  • If your school is already perfect in every way, you don’t need this to be reading this anyhow; the wind will just blow Mary Poppins to you

MAXIM #2—Know thyself as an institution and a culture; keep these things in mind:
  • Your mission
  • Core values
  • Who works well in your community
  • Your ideals
  • Your institutional needs—on a moral and social-emotional level, not just practical
  • Your community—what it is, what it is like

MAXIM #3—It takes a school to hire a teacher
  • Build a hiring team comprised of more or less the same people/functions for every hire
  • Advertise smart
  • Interview smart
  • Use the candidate as a mirror; what do you learn about the school as your community “presents” itself?

MAXIM #4—You can always get what you want
  • Advertise smart
  • Advertise broadly
  • Work a little harder
  • Be patient
Corollary A: Diversity: There is no excuse for failure
  • Know what you mean, mean what you say
  • A little humility goes a long way
  • Advertise smart
  • Try harder
Corollary B: Cannon fodder: There is no excuse for hiring “expendable”teachers
  • If you’re a school, hire teachers, not just live bodies
  • Don’t give up before you start; don’t hire just to get it over with
  • Dorms matter, teams matter, and classes matter—but students matter more
  • Be prepared to give people the proper tools to do a proper job
  • “Good enough” isn’t

MAXIM #5—Check it out
  • Check all references
  • Do the most thorough background checks you can do
  • Got vans? How about checking driving records?

MAXIM #6—Induction matters
  • Make your initial investment count
  • And make an initial investment in time and effort
  • Know thyself and bring each new teacher into the learning and living community
Corollary: There is a reason that Mentor shows up early in The Odyssey; make sure your mentors show up early, too
  • It’s a tough journey for a new teacher—provide a map and a guide
  • Be alert for where your new hires are going to encounter minefields, mind games, and milestones

MAXIM #7—Good teachers can be made
  • You must believe this
  • Provide access, opportunity, and feedback
  • More opportunity, more feedback
  • Be specific

MAXIM #8—School culture is everything. Do all that you can to make yours both inviting and welcoming.
  • Be a learning community
  • Be a civil community
  • Be an honest community
  • Be a loving community
  • Foster cross-generational cross-fertilization

MAXIM #9—Not everybody wants an office
  • Administration: not for everyone
  • Support ambition, honor commitment, develop real leadership; even your youngest and newest can be leaders
  • Not all leaders are administrators, not all administrators are leaders (and not everyone needs to be)
  • But don’t stint on providing opportunity

MAXIM #10—Needs matter
  • Tailor-make benefits for all ages and stages
  • Be serious, and try harder
  • Beware the curses of paternalism: dependency, cynicism, complacency

​MAXIM #11—Old dogs actually like to learn new tricks
  • And they can learn them
  • Access and opportunity are for everyone
  • In a learning community, learning is supposed to be fun and rewarding; is this true with professional learning in yours?
Corollary: But some old dogs like to find their own tricks
  • “I don’t want to know a trick until I’ve seen it work”
  • But teach a man to fish…
  • Bartleby was, after all, a lousy employee in the role he was assigned; sometimes it’s worth asking what someone might prefer

MAXIM #12—All things must end
  • We know why: “cause,” “employment at will”; we hear the war stories
  • Sometimes it’s time: counseling out
  • Counseling for growth
  • Managing exit strategies
  • Preparing the chute
  • The Glorious End
An awkward cautionary Corollary: Don’t be stupid
  • We’ve all read the newspaper stories about schools that gently moved problematic teachers along
  • You want your school in the Boston Globe‘s Spotlight?
A much sweeter (but sometimes extremely bittersweet) Corollary: Be nicer than you ever thought you could be
  • Sometimes the end comes in the hardest, cruelest way, often unexpected; know how you will honor lives that end in your community
  • Whether someone left, retired, or died in harness, they gave a part of their life to your school, your students, and your community. Honor this in full, and never forget!
0 Comments

Book Review: Sweller’s Cognitive Load Theory in Action

12/5/2022

0 Comments

 
Picture
Dr. Diane Martin
Dr. Diane Martin, Director of Divisions at Wooster School, and participant in the Association for Academic Leaders Upper School Division Heads cohort series, reviews Sweller’s Cognitive Load Theory in Action by Oliver Lovell.
This immensely digestible and immediately useful book includes both the instructional theory, with all the necessary details about human cognition, and the practical, meaningful, and not difficult to implement ways that Cognitive Load Theory (CLT) can be applied in the classroom. ​
​The author begins with a quote (originally tweeted in 2017) that was the impetus for his investigation of Cognitive Load Theory:
I’ve come to the conclusion Sweller’s Cognitive Load Theory is the single most important thing for teachers to know - Dylan Wiliam
Lovell’s deep dive into the literature and theory led to this book, which begins with providing an understanding of the five key principles of CLT, followed by practical application and strategies.  

Lovell explains the five principles that underpin CLT in terms of A, B, C, D and E:
  • A – Architecture
  • B – Biologically primary vs. secondary knowledge
  • C – Categorising load as intrinsic or extraneous 
  • D – Domain-general vs. domain specific knowledge
  • E – Element interactivity

These five principles can help instructional designers consider intrinsic load (the core learning that should occupy students’ working memory) while they seek to reduce extraneous load (associated with the manner and structure of instruction).

While the author says that the theory section can be skipped I believe it  is an essential review. This section is, perhaps, one of the clearest descriptions of the role of working memory I have encountered. The author explains the ways in which an understanding of cognitive load can help to increase the efficiency of working memory. Included in this description are specific descriptions of intrinsic load and extraneous load. Academic leaders should not skip this section!  

To manage cognitive load in the classroom, teachers and instructional designers should look for ways to reduce the extraneous cognitive load using elements of design and structure, while optimizing the intrinsic load using a variety of solid instructional strategies. The book includes bolded key terms and text boxes, allowing for quick access, review, and application of strategies, such as pre-teaching and segmentation, to a detailed description of the modality effect to expand working memory capacity. The strategies included apply equally to those planning for a classroom of students or a conference room of professionals. Reading this work can not only  help us be better teachers and leaders, but can also offer insights to help the readers better understand themselves as learners.​
0 Comments
<<Previous

    Don't miss our weekly blog posts by joining our newsletter mailing list below:

    Authors

    Brad Rathgeber (he/him/his)
    CEO & Head of School
    Beta Eaton (she/her/hers)
    Director of Student Support
    Corinne Dedini (she/her/hers)
    Senior Director,  Academics
    Elizabeth Katz (she/her/hers)
    Senior Director, School Partnership
    Kerry Smith (she/her/hers)
    Instructional Designer for Professional Development
    Peter Gow (he/him/his)
    Independent Curriculum Resource Director
    Sarah Hanawald (she/her/hers)
    Senior Director, PD & New Programs
    Sienna Brancato (she/her/hers)
    Program Manager for PD & New Programs
    Tracie Yorke (she/her/hers)
    Instructional Designer for Equity, Inclusive Innovation & Accessibility
    ​Lorri Palko (she/her/hers)
    Finance & Operations Advisor; CFO (retired)
    Karen Douse (she/her/hers)
    Director of School & Student Support (retired)

    Archives

    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    March 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    March 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    September 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    October 2013
    August 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    October 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    May 2012
    March 2012
    November 2011
    October 2011
    July 2011
    June 2002

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Organization

About
Welcome
​History
FAQs
​Calendar
​
Team Members
Board of Trustees
Employment Opportunities
© COPYRIGHT 2020, ONE SCHOOLHOUSE, INC.. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

Policies

Tuition & Policies
Equity and Inclusion & Non-Discrimination Policy
Technology Requirements & Policies
​Privacy Policy

School Resources

Advanced Independent Curriculum
​Partner Professional Learning Courses

Get In Touch

Have any questions?
Send us an email or give us a call.
info@oneschoolhouse.org
202.618.3637

​1701 Rhode Island Ave NW
Washington, DC 20036


We'd love to hear from you!​